Lessons Learned in 2011: A Direct Marketer’s Perspective

We couldn’t have said it better ourselves. 2011 WAS a very good year from a direct marketing perspective. As it turned out, the year was filled with hunches confirmed, tests proven and insights gleaned….regardless of the client.

As experts in the industry, the Direct Choice Staff has decided to share their thoughts on  the most significant lessons learned in 2011 from their perspective:

The Direct Choice Family

  • Karin: I would say, stick with what works. My clients have been tasked with saving money, and can’t afford to put a wrong  foot forward. We took our controls, made them even stronger and strengthened the branding aspects to support the retail level, and then off we went. Our programs have been pulling hard for several years, and thank goodness, they did even better this year.
  • Nick R.: Qualifying the lead pays off. It was the client’s prospect list, so we used messaging to deliver a serious lead, instead of a so-so one. We delivered more sales than the current control, which is what really matters.
  • Anne: Creative matters. I say it every year, but this year it was REALLY important.
  • Mike: “Couldn’t have said it better than Anne.”
  • Christine: At a time when budgets are tight, we are making it work! Drilling down on the data is yielding some incredible results. We customized our messaging and went back out there to a tightly targeted file, speaking to them about what we knew really resonated with them. I would say that in any marketplace a 24% response rate is extraordinary…but at this time and in this economy, it is truly amazing.
  • Nick L.: Tuning in to the budgets for each client. I know it sounds really boring, but in this kind of year, that’s where the victories are. That and reinvention. It’s a time to review where you are at, where you are going, and set up a different navigation path.
  • Scott: Innovation that can bring down cost per lead has been the name of the game. Whether that’s reducing paper, implementing a digital communications build-out, and looking at every communication contact for its efficacy…it’s been critical.
  • Beth: There are no sacred cows. In 2011 and into 2012, everything has been up for taking a second hard look.

These are all wise words to take into 2012, and if you follow this blog, we will have many more to share throughout the year. What were your lessons learned?

—-

Direct Choice Inc. is a full-service direct marketing agency that has worked with national and regional brands in a wide variety of vertical markets. In addition to this blog, you can also find us on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and LinkedIn.

Prospecting: The Real vs. The Brand

You’ve invested a lot of $$$$ in your brand. Why? Because the conventional wisdom is that it is the age of the brand and no longer about “advertising” (sorry Don Draper). Sorry to say, but the era of the fabulous campaign that makes you think as you sit captive to the boob tube every night is a bygone relic.

So, as long as your brand is resonant, your image is clear and competitively delineated, your website and your materials carry forth all those brand characteristics,…then you are assured of success, right?

Wrong……Brand-schmand (I know, spoken like a true marketer, you might say).

The truth is they are both necessary. While marketing is all about the P’s (Product, Place, Price, Promotion), branding exists in a more esoteric universe.

  • Marketing separates; brand unifies.
  • Marketing is about segmenting a big group of people, and targeting them with the proper market mix. Branding preaches the unifying element that combines.

In general, branding assures that a product stands for the same thing to a15 year- old kid and a 50 year-old plumber.

If true prospect marketing had its own way, Coca Cola, for example, would have to create a marketing mix for each segment or demographic – teens, ‘tweens, kids, oldies, etc. But, because Coca Cola is at the end of the day a brand and not a product, it preaches the singular message that “Coke is the real thing,” and that one message brings us to one platform & one positioning….from Alaska to Australia.

But how would we prospect most cost-effectively for Coke? Ah. That is the province of the marketer. One retail chain owner recently came up empty-handed after spending a ton on TV advertising to drive traffic into his stores. After an initial surge, his stores were empty. Under siege from shareholders, he came to us at Direct Choice to do, as he put it, the “boots on the ground stuff” to get his outlets busy.

As lead generators, we knew it wasn’t all about his brand. It was about smart micro-targeting in the neighborhoods, leveraging online tactics, special offers and incentives, and buzz in the local markets. Most of all, it was really about knowing who his customers are—and therefore who his best prospects really were.

His branding work had been done. Then it was up to us to make it pay off. Branding and Marketing working in harmony.

—-

Direct Choice Inc. is a full-service direct marketing agency that has worked with national and regional brands in a wide variety of vertical markets. In addition to this blog, you can also find us on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and LinkedIn.

Insurers and Customer Relationship Management: How You Should Communicate (and what you should say)

Fact of life: communicating with customers — whether they are individual policyholders or a small group — makes sense (and that means before your base becomes vulnerable to a competitor’s market attack or lower-priced offerings)

Does that mean a multimillion dollar data and modeling project to determine who’s “worth it”? No. But it does mean laying down some low-cost communications as part of an overall customer relationship management strategy. Remember that most customers/members never hear from their insurer. This is what needs to change…IMMEDIATELY

Start with your customer database. Are you collecting and keeping member email addresses? If not, start gathering them during the application process. Have your brokers and agents do the same. And then, once a sample is gathered, begin with a low-cost email campaign of a few contacts per year with  live links to your website.

But what should you say? The first and most obvious opportunity is the “Thank You/Welcome”. Get new members used to this channel as a form of regular communication. Include an invitation to manage their account online (again, with a link to your website). Don’t forget, a member who is contacting you with questions is a member who is more likely to stay with you. Can you provide new members with their own Customer Service Representative? Divvy up onboarding members with your most friendly CSRs for live chat/email contact. After all, we all like to know there is someone there for us.

What’s next? Build out your communications plan during the first 6 months and add one or two more contact points with your new members. Direct mail fulfillment of the member card and policy materials is a good follow-up to the initial contact and a good channel to continue to build engagement opportunities. An email reminder of an often-overlooked benefit—such as dental or vision discounts, or wellness coverage—can provide value-driven content for that one additional contact at low cost.

Again, the point is to provide relevant engagements, not meaningless, pesky contact.

Does a new member have a pre-existing condition or disease to manage, such as diabetes or obesity? Helping those members sign up for additional support and management tools/programs from the start can build strong relationships and increase member stick power. Perhaps an outbound call or email is not only good medical business, but it can be a comfort if handled well.

So now you’ve welcomed them, handed out new member materials, and successfully engaged those needing support. What about the rest of the year? How much is enough, vs. too much, Customer Relationship Management? The answer is based on a simple question: how much can you afford to invest to keep this member?

In our final post of the series, we will help you figure out that answer.

—-

Direct Choice Inc. is a full-service direct marketing agency that has worked with national and regional brands in a wide variety of vertical markets. In addition to this blog, you can also find us on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and LinkedIn.